Archive for February 18th, 2010

Notes From Underground: never “DISCOUNT” the pain caused by the markets

February 18, 2010

The FED “surprised” the markets when it raised the discount rate after the equtiy markets had closed, which prompted a large buying of the DOLLAR and the selling of everything else. Earlier today, we wrote a piece about flattening and steepening curves and the impact they had on the markets. We thought the curve (2/10) would have flattened after the FOMC release but that did not take place and the markets all reacted positively to the renewed steepening action.

Post-FED action, the 2/10 Treasury curve has started to flatten, taking down everything in its path. We do not argue with price action so we respect what we are seeing at this juncture. We think that the DISCOUNT RATE RISE is not a big deal as it moves the discount to a 50 basis point premium to Fed Funds. The Federal Reserve statement went out of its way to ensure the markets that there was no change in monetary policy, but the market action dictated that we should pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.

To us this FED action indicates that the Fed is going to raise the rate on RESERVE DEPOSITS very soon as it begins testing its theory on how to remove the vast amounts of liquidity from the system. It will also prompt the use of reverse-repos soon, and by soon we think that could mean Friday. If the FED does initiate these next steps tomorrow, it should lead to more flattening of the curve and further selling of all risk assets. We will be watching closely for if the FED does indeed act and the markets were to slough it off, that would be the real story but that gets us too far ahead of ourselves.

At the end of the day a .75% DISCOUNT RATE is no big deal, especially when borrowings from the FED emergency facilities have been greatly reduced already. (And, as we need to remind everyone, if inflation is 1.5% and interest rates are still below 1% you still have negative real rates still feeding the market.) This is no time for heroes but rather cautious weighing of market action to truly signify if a sea change is upon us. As always-2+2=5 in an unbalanced world.

Notes From Underground: IMF gold sales+FOMC minutes = a steepening yield curve

February 18, 2010

The IMF announced that they will sell the remaining 197 tons of GOLD of the previously-agreed 400 tons. The IMF made the initial announcement Sept. 18, 2009 and you can consult your charts to see the impact it made on that Friday to the following Monday. The initial 200 tons that were sold were done in a negotiated sale with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) at the beginning of November. This time the IMF will sell the GOLD in the market at much smaller amounts which should not make our friends in Beijing very happy. It is interesting how the IMF overseers determine when to make this announcement and why it isn’t done in the morning when the markets are more robust and able to handle the news in a more liquid environment. Oh well, the market has digested, and as we write, GOLD has actually turned higher from the COMEX pit close of yesterday.

The FED released FOMC minutes yesterday and there was little that was new. But the pundits were busy concentrating on how much time was devoted to the discussion of removing the stimulus the FED has provided, and especially how to rid itself of all the mortgage-backed securities on its balance sheet. Traders seem to have taken this to mean that there was an imminent tightening to take place via the selling of the MBSs. If the FED was to tighten, we wondered why the yield curve (2/10 Treasury spread) did not flatten on the news. In discussions with others we respect, they made the point that the long-end failed to rally because of the knowledge that the FED has so much long-end to sell off. We say fair enough, but we can’t help but focus on the fact that with such a large negative output gap and the FED removing stimulus, the yield curve OUGHT to flatten somewhat–and the market did not react that way at all.

In fact, as we write, the curve is STEEPENING further, which we believe is giving a bid to equities and other assets. The FED has really created  a mutant curve with its robust quantitative easing, and, as we have stated previously, the FED has ill served the market and the market will exact its price.  Many have written that the mortgage markets have been held artificially low, which prevents investors from taking part in the mortgage market. As the FED starts selling off their purchases, the market will demand higher rates to make up for past discrepancies. This is what the FED models fail to perceive. This steepening curve is more than interesting to watch for its impact will drive investment decisions and it will make the DOLLAR uneasy after the EURO concerns diminish.

But Philadelphia FED President Charles Plosser’s speech was lost in yesterday’s market drivers. His speech was on the theme of the need for the FED to return its balance sheet to pre-crisis levels. He criticized the FED for overreach for its aggressive use of article 13.3 of the Federal Reserve Act for Treasury securities. Under duress, the FED took collateral on their balance sheet that they need to remove sooner rather then later. He also stressed that the FED needs to remove itself  from blurring the lines of monetary and fiscal policy as they did by invoking 13.3. We finish up by citing a quote from Plosser which we would all do  remember:

“We live in a world of highly mobile capital and financial markets that are constantly assessing the credibility of governments and their central banks to maintain price and economic stability. In such a world, the mere threat that monetary policy might become politicized can damage the nation’s credibility. It can raise fears of inflation that send interest rates higher and currencies falling.”